South-Western - Management  
Research Finds 'Motherhood Penalty' in Employment Process
Topic Equal Employment Opportunity
Key Words motherhood penalty, glass ceiling, bias
News Story

A new study from Cornell University found that mothers were penalized in the hiring process compared to childless women and men. Researchers set up a mock company and had male and female students evaluate applications for a marketing position. With all qualifications being equal, the evaluators said they would hire 84 percent of the women without children, but only 47 percent of the mothers. Additionally, the study found that mothers were offered lower salaries than women without children, with a salary gap as much as $11,000 in starting wages.

Both male and female evaluators were equally biased against women with children, which was surprising to the researchers since many of the students grew up with working mothers themselves.

In addition to the motherhood penalty, the study discovered a fatherhood bonus since evaluators assumed "breadwinning" fathers would be more dedicated to their jobs than men without children. Researchers say the study reinforces the "glass ceiling" barrier that prevents women, particularly mothers, from advancing to top-ranking positions.

Questions
1.

Research "glass ceiling" in your text. As an HR manager, what steps could you take to prevent this situation in your company?

2.

According to the study, motherhood and career are viewed as largely incompatible. How does an HR manager separate a candidate's personal life from professional abilities?

Source "Research Finds 'Motherhood Penalty' in Employment Process," Society for Human Resources Management, August 12, 2005.
Instructor Discussion Notes Discussion Notes
These notes are restricted to qualified instructors only. Register for free!

Return to the Equal Employment Opportunity Index

©2005  South-Western.  All Rights Reserved     |