South-Western - Management  
Corporate Goal: Ethnic Variety, No Quotas
Topic Equal Employment Opportunity
Key Words Affirmative action, quotas, diversity
News Story

Many companies celebrated the Supreme Court decision that supported the University of Michigan's affirmative action policy. The decision affirms that you can consider race on the grounds that you're seeking to obtain a diverse workplace environment. But the court also made it clear that any hiring process resembling a quota system probably isn't legal. The ruling could force significant rethinking of corporate policies for personnel ratings and compensation, such as management bonuses for diversity goals.

While companies have made great strides in recruiting minorities over the past decade, those workers still have higher rates of attrition than other workers, and remain thinly represented in management ranks. Minority employees, including managers, tend to occupy a disproportionate degree of lower-ranking staff jobs that carry less prestige and often less pay. Of the nation's 500 largest companies, only three are led by African-Americans.

Virtually all large companies have affirmative action plans in place, especially if they deal with the federal government, but they rarely offer more than broad, long-term goals. Some experts hope that by knocking out quotas, the decision could encourage more creative ways of hiring and interacting with minorities beyond the recruiting stage, such as purchasing from minority businesses and serving minority clients. However, the use of preference programs to steer contracts to women and minority-owned businesses is already under legal assault.

Questions
1.

This Supreme Court decision has some huge implications for businesses and their affirmative action programs. For instance, in her decision, Justice O'Connor predicted that in another twenty-five years, racial preferences would no longer be necessary. Does this mean the end of affirmative action? What do you think, and how do you feel about it?

Source "Corporate Goal: Ethnic Variety, No Quotas," The Wall Street Journal, June 24, 2003, p. B1.
Instructor Discussion Notes Discussion Notes
These notes are restricted to qualified instructors only. Register for free!

Return to the Equal Employment Opportunity Index

©2004  South-Western.  All Rights Reserved     |