South-Western - Management  
How Will The U.S. Fill Its Benefit Gap?
Topic Employee Benefits
Key Words Employee benefits, pension plans, health insurance,
InfoTrac Reference A142348030
If your textbook came with an InfoTrac passcode, click here to login on InfoTrac.
News Story

In China, state-owned enterprises once provided its workers with health and pension benefits as well as housing and wages. As the economy in China has changed, workers have had to look elsewhere to meet their needs. Today, less than 20% of the Chinese have health insurance. In a similar fashion, U.S. employers long have provided their workers with health care and pension benefits. The system began during World War II and stayed stable for decades because American companies faced little competition and could afford to share the wealth with their employees.

However, this system of protection for the American worker is cracking. Big U.S. companies are wriggling out of their pension promises. Healthy companies are moving their old pension plans into defined-contribution plans such as 401(k)s which shift the risk of savings to workers themselves. And 42.4% of private-sector workers age 21 or older aren't offered any pension plan at work.

Health insurance benefits are also being scaled back. Nearly 60% of Americans are covered by their employer, but the percentage keeps slipping. As health and pension benefits have turned out to be more costly than employers realized, companies keep cutting costs to stay competitive. Competition includes foreign companies, where the government bears most of the cost of employee benefits, and upstart rivals that aren't burdened with retirees.

The question facing America right now is who is going to meet the needs of the American people when corporations get out of the health insurance and pension business. There are three options, each with their own set of problems:

  • Make it cheaper for employers to offer benefits or force them to do so: business resists this option.
  • Make workers fend for themselves: many individuals find it harder to make these types of decisions than advocates would suggest.
  • Have government pick up the tab: can undermine the benefits of pooling risk; also where will the government get the money?


  • Questions
    1.

    Research benefits around the world in your textbook. How does the U.S. compare to at least two other countries when it comes to providing health insurance and pension benefits to its citizens? Be prepared to share your findings in class to help compile a comparative chart.

    2.

    The article suggests that one solution to the benefits problem going forward is that companies could be mandated to provide benefits to their workers. Are U.S. companies mandated to provide any benefits to their workers today? What are these government-mandated benefits, if any?

    3.

    The article states that many companies are making the change from a traditional pension plan to a defined-contribution pension plan. What are the differences and why do workers bear the risk of the second type of plan but not the first?

    4.

    The author of the article lays out three possibilities for how the U.S. will fill the benefits gap going forward. Which possibility do you think is the most feasible and why? List at least three reasons and be prepared to discuss your ideas in class.

    Source "How Will The U.S. Fill Its Benefit Gap?" WSJ Online, April 13, 2006, Page A2.
    Instructor Discussion Notes Discussion Notes
    These notes are restricted to qualified instructors only. Register for free!

    Return to the Employee Benefits Index

    ©2006  South-Western.  All Rights Reserved     |